The Center for Biological Diversity recently filed a petition to attempt to halt the collection of native wild turtles in Arkansas. These turtles are being harvested for two primary reasons: 1) the pet trade, and 2) the asian food market. Members of the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission met with "turtlers", as the people who do the collecting/selling are called, and as a result tabled the petition and decided to allow the harvest to continue. Many other states have halted the harvest, as they realize it is threatening their populations, but, as with many things, Arkansas is falling behind on this. Please send an email to Mr. Armstrong at
marmstrong@agfc.state.ar.us requesting the halt of native turtle harvest in Arkansas! Here is some background information:
Dear Audubon friends and others,
On Monday, June 8, the Fisheries Div. of Arkansas Game and Fish met to talk with all interested parties about whether or not to make changes in the Aquatic Turtle Regulations that deal with the commercial harvest of freshwater aquatic turtles. (Please note that these regulations do not cover those turtles that are "farmed" on private property.)
At the meeting it was AGFC staff, mainly turtle dealers, harvesters and farmers, and three of us were there in support of more restrictive regulations and optimally, a ban on the commercial harvest of freshwater turtles.
As you'll recall, in March 2009, the Center for Biological Diversity filed an Emergency Rulemaking Request to Repeal Arkansas' Turtle Collection Law with the AGFC and also the State Health Department. Audubon Society of Central Arkansas is one of the petitioners.
Neither agency deemed it an emergency, so the emergency rulemaking request is now a moot point. The link for the original petition is attached. It's a bit lengthy, but has excellent background and research information for requesting the ban.
At the June 8 meeting, Kelly Irwin, Staff Herpetologist, had prepared a sheet with suggested changes that would be more restrictive, and the "turtlers" were not happy. There was dialogue back and forth for several hours and the plan was that the turtlers would go back to their groups and then offer their suggestions. We were going to do the same as we waited for revisions in order to take action, but then yesterday we learned that the proposed changes had been pulled down and there would be no revisions to the Aquatic Turtle Regulations to begin in Jan., 2010.
Disappointed and surprised? Very!!
All that we know right now is that it's a Staff decision and not AGFC Administration decision, so we'll continue with our plan to get as many emails out as possible to Mike Armstrong, Fisheries Division Chief. Mr. Armstrong told me that we could submit comment on the petition by Center for Biological Diversity, and now that there are no proposed changes, I’m hoping that we can mount this effort to turn that around with our emails. And if you can't get one out with such short notice, please send one at your earliest convenience since this is a topic that the Fisheries Div. can continue to consider in the coming months.
Mr. Armstrong's email address is marmstrong@agfc.state.ar.us
Pertinent points are that the turtle harvest is not sustainable and the harvest numbers reported from 2004 through 2008 have steadily declined. The numbers have dropped from 250,437 in 2004 to 85,424 in 2008. We do not know if this indicates an actual decline in populations or just a reduction in the reporting by the harvesters or even the method of the reporting. Moreover, we have no studies to know current populations for any kind of turtle in Arkansas.
There is a naturally high mortality rate in turtle nests, hatchlings and juveniles, and maintaining the stability of long lived breeding adults is necessary to maintain populations. Predation with eggs and hatchlings in the wild is much more of a problem now too with greater numbers of fire ants and larger numbers of raccoons, and this would certainly be the time to curtail rather than continue the unabated commercial harvest of our freshwater turtles.
There is also the question of food safety as these turtles are being caught in the same streams and waters for which the Ark. Dept. of Health has fish advisories in place. The potential for contamination with PCBs , pesticides, and heavy metals needs to be established and to date, this has not been done. (It should also be noted that at the meeting on June 8, most turtlers claimed that the majority of the turtles being caught are for the pet trade or for breeding stock for Asian turtle farms and not for food.)
The pressures being placed on Arkansas turtles are now even greater. Oklahoma in 2008 placed a three year moratorium while studying the status of Oklahoma's s wild turtle populations, the effects of the commercial harvest and the potential contamination of turtles sold as food. Texas voted to ban the commercial collection of native TX turtles on public land and waters in 2007. On Monday, June 17, FL will rule whether or not to ban all harvesting of freshwater turtles, and GA is currently developing recommendations for potential legislative action. Further, Illinois, North Carolina, Alabama and MS have already banned the commercial harvest of all native freshwater turtles.
Why is it that Arkansas is doing nothing? We are not even considering if a moratorium or a ban is needed.
When turtles are shipped live from Arkansas, it’s not known the size or the numbers of turtles, but only a total weight for each kind, so again, it would seem that more information is needed. We do not know actual numbers that are being removed from the state, legally or illegally.
Do know too that Bill Shepherd has been heading up this effort for our chapter and is currently away, and as time is of the essence, I’ve taken the liberty to send out this email. I did submit the letter that he wrote in advance on behalf of the chapter, and that letter has been given to Mike Armstrong.
Sources used in this letter were the Petition from the Center for Biological Diversity, Commercial Aquatic Turtle Harvest Report 2004 -2006 by Kelly Irwin, Herpetological Program Supervisor, Ark. Raw Harvest Numbers from 2007 and 2008, meeting notes from June 8, 2009 and other sources, mainly newspaper articles.
Your email does not need to be long and I apologize that this one is so lengthy, but please, if you can find a few spare minutes, send that email to marmstrong@agfc.state.ar.us requesting a ban or a moratorium on the commercial harvest of native aquatic turtles.
Also free to cut and paste whatever you want from this letter or to send it on to anyone else that you think would be interested. The campaign will continue!
Thanks,
Susan Hardin